HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS British Journal of Psychiatry Advances in Psychiatric Treatment All RCPsych Journals		QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced] Author: Keyword(s): Year:  Vol:  Page:

This Article Abstract Full Text (PDF) Submit an eLetter Alert me when this article is cited Alert me when eLetters are posted Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via CrossRef Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Clafferty, R. A. Articles by Brown, K. W. Search for Related Content PubMed Articles by Clafferty, R. A. Articles by Brown, K. W.

Conspiracy of silence? Telling patients with schizophrenia their diagnosis

Forth Valley Primary Care NHS Trust, Old Denny Road, Larbert FK5 4SD

	Abstract

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
AIMS AND METHOD

We undertook a postal questionnaire survey of all consultant psychiatrists working in Scotland to examine whether psychiatrists themselves may contribute to the misunderstandings surrounding schizophrenia by avoiding discussion of the diagnosis with their patients.

RESULTS

Two-hundred and forty-six (76%) responded. Ninety-five per cent thought the consultant psychiatrist was the most appropriate person to tell a patient their diagnosis of schizophrenia, although only 59% reported doing so in the first established episode of schizophrenia, rising to 89% for recurrent schizophrenia. Fifteen per cent would not use the term ‘schizophrenia’ and a variety of confusing terminology was reported. Over 95% reported telling patients they had mood disorders or anxiety, under 50% that they had dementia or personality disorders.

CLINICAL IMPLICATION

Greater openness by psychiatrists about the diagnosis of schizophrenia may be an essential first step in reducing stigma.

	Introduction

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
Fuelled by recent inquiries into the apparent failure of psychiatric care (Department of Health and Social Security, 1988; Ritchie, 1994) and sensational media reports, society's view of schizophrenia is largely negative. Although the Royal College of Psychiatrists (‘Every Family in the Land: Recommendations for the Implementation of a Five-year Strategy: 1998-2003’; available upon request from the External Affairs and Information Services Department, The Royal College of Psychiatrists, 17 Belgrave Square, London SW1X 8PG) and World Health Organization (Sartorius, 1997) have launched campaigns to reduce the stigma of mental illness, psychiatrists themselves have been implicated in contributing to misunderstandings about schizophrenia by withholding information from their patients (Svensson & Hanson, 1994; Leavey et al, 1997), giving them confusing information (Main et al, 1993; Barker et al, 1996) and of being reluctant to tell them their diagnosis (McDonald-Scott et al, 1992; Luderer & Bocker, 1993).

	The study

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
All consultant psychiatrists working in Scotland in May 1997 (n=323; from a database supplied by the information and statistics division of the NHS in Scotland) were sent a questionnaire asking their opinion and practice on telling psychiatric patients their diagnosis (copies available from authors upon request). Ninety-five per cent confidence intervals (95% CIs) for proportions and their differences were calculated.

	Findings

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
Response rate
Two hundred and forty-six questionnaires were returned (76% response rate). Thirty-five were excluded from analysis: 25 respondents stated the topic was not relevant to their speciality, five were not practicing in clinical psychiatry, four questionnaires were spoiled and one respondent no longer worked in Scotland.

Characteristics of the respondents
We achieved a 76% response rate. Seventy-seven (36%; 95% CI 30-43%) were women. One hundred and four (49%; 95% CI 42-56%) had been consultants for over 10 years. Women were a smaller proportion of the latter group — 24% compared with 49% of those with 10 years' experience or less (a difference of 25%; 95% CI 12-37%).

Telling the diagnosis to different diagnostic groups
Consultants were asked if it was their normal clinical practice to inform patients who met standard diagnostic criteria of their exact diagnosis (Fig. 1).

View larger version (8K): [in this window] [in a new window]   Figure 1. Percentage of consultants who would tell patients their exact diagnosis (Confidence Intervals).

The highest positive response was for unipolar depression (207; 98%; 95% CI 96-100%), followed closely by bipolar disorder, anxiety disorder and alcohol or drug misuse. In cases where the diagnosis of schizophrenia was not in doubt, 187 (89%; 95% CI 84-93%) would tell the diagnosis in a recurrent episode; 124 (59%; 95% CI 52-65%) would tell the diagnosis in a first episode. A minority would tell a diagnosis of dementia or personality disorder — 92 (44%; 95% CI 37-50%) and 88 (42%; 95% CI 35-48%), respectively.

Telling patients they have schizophrenia
A variety of terms were used (Table 1). Two hundred (95%; 95% CI 9-98%) thought a consultant psychiatrist, perhaps with other staff, would be the best person to give the diagnosis. Various approaches were reported: 157 (74%; 95% CI 69-80%) would give the diagnosis as part of a routine consultation and 63 (30%; 95% CI 24-36%) would arrange a separate appointment, with 189 (90%; 95% CI 85-94%) meeting relatives if the patient consented. Most would give information about voluntary organisations (171; 81%; 95% CI 76-86%); 103 (49%; 95% CI 42-56%) gave written information; 84 (40%; 95% CI 33-46%) recommended books and 76 (36%; 95% CI 30-43%) referred the patient to an education group run by local psychiatric services. Only 108 (51%; 95% CI 44-58%) would volunteer the diagnosis without being asked. A variety of comments and experiences were reported (Table 2).

Differences between groups of respondents
A higher proportion of women consultants volunteered the diagnosis of schizophrenia without being asked (56% v. 46%; 49% CI for the difference: 5-23%), referred the patient to self-help groups (88% v. 77%; 95% CI for the difference: 1-22%) and met with relatives to discuss the diagnosis (94% v. 87%; 95% CI for the difference: 2-4%).

Consultants in post for more than 10 years were more likely to feel uncomfortable telling the diagnosis of schizophrenia (47% v. 38%, a difference of 9%; 95% CI 5-22%) and were less likely to volunteer the diagnosis without being asked (42% v. 60%, a difference of 18%; 95% CI 14-31%).

Open text comments
A number of enlightening comments were received and the following list records some common themes:

1. "I give patients my formulation and don't normally give a diagnosis."
   
2. "... Experience of people with schizophrenia who commit suicide would suggest that insight is a factor in a number of cases. This emphasises the potentially devastating effect of knowledge of diagnosis and the importance of handling the information with extreme care and support."
   
3. "... I am impressed by the number of people with schizophrenia who I meet who do not know their diagnosis and the largely positive effects telling the diagnosis has."
   
4. "The most important thing in giving the diagnosis is to try to ensure they are ready to receive it and that they want to know the details."
   
5. "Knowledge of the diagnosis allows information and education on the subject."
   
6. "My problem is that I don't believe schizophrenia exists — even though there's a lot of it about."
   
7. "I don't know what standard diagnostic criteria are, but I know a schizophrenic when I've interviewed the relatives and he walks through the door."
   
8. "The consequences of schizophrenia in terms of social adaptation and symptoms cannot be hidden."
   

	Discussion

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
Doctors have a duty to give patients information in a way that is understandable to them (General Medical Council, 1998). They must decide how much information to give and how and when to give it, but not avoid the issue or presume patients do not want to know (Pendleton & Hasler, 1983). Avoiding discussion of diagnosis may only heighten patients' anxieties (Carstairs et al, 1985).

Giving patients with schizophrenia information about their illness is recommended in good practice statements (CRAG-SCOTMEG Working Group on Mental Illness, 1995) and clinical guidelines (American Psychiatric Association, 1997; Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, 1998). Informed patients may enjoy many potential benefits: better engagement with services (Foulks et al, 1986; Bebbington, 1995); improved knowledge (Smith et al, 1992); higher quality of life (Atkinson et al, 1996); and reduced negative symptoms (Goldman & Quinn, 1988). Uninformed patients may discover their diagnosis in a distressing way, such as on a form, at court or when accessing their records (Atkinson, 1984). They may not access voluntary sector services or may give incorrect information in benefit claims or housing applications. They may not know their responsibility to notify the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency about their fitness to drive (DVLA, 1995).

There can be risks and difficulties in informing patients they have schizophrenia. The risk of suicide, thought to be highest early in the illness and associated with insight (King, 1994; Amador et al, 1996), must be assessed in each patient. Some psychiatrists do not use the diagnosis of schizophrenia even after the introduction of operationally defined criteria (World Health Organization, 1992; American Psychiatric Association, 1994), preferring their own idiosyncratic diagnostic system (Saugstad & Odegard, 1983). There is some debate about the validity of making a diagnosis of schizophrenia (Clafferty et al, 2000; Fisher, 2000; King, 2000), which is outside the remit of our study — we asked psychiatrists only about established illness where the diagnosis was not in doubt. Psychiatrists have been accused of using stigmatising labels (Lally, 1989), but stigma arises from the symptoms and signs of the illness itself, not merely its name (Penn et al, 1994).

Society's prejudice towards people with schizophrenia may improve with current education campaigns, but a change in psychiatric practice may also be necessary. When psychiatrists are willing to break free from the conspiracy of silence surrounding schizophrenia, the public may follow their example.

	References

Top Abstract Introduction The study Findings Discussion References

 
AMADOR, X. F., FRIEDMAN, J. H., KASAPIS, C., et al (1996) Suicidal behaviour in schizophrenia and its relationship to awareness of illness. American Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 1185-1188.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (Fourth Edn). Washington: APA.

AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION (1997) Practice guidelines for the treatment of patients with schizophrenia. American Journal of Psychiatry, 154 (suppl. 4).

ATKINSON, J. M. (1984) To tell or not to tell the diagnosis of schizophrenia. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2, 1-24.[Medline]

ATKINSON, J. M., COIA, D. A., GILMOUR, W. H., et al (1996) The impact of education groups for people with schizophrenia on social functioning and quality of life. British Journal of Psychiatry, 168, 199-204.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

BARKER, D. A., SHERGILL, S. S., HIGGINSON, I., et al (1996) Patients' views towards care received from psychiatrists. British Journal of Psychiatry, 168, 641-646.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

BEBBINGTON, P. E. (1995) The content and context of compliance. International Clinical Psychopharmacology, 9, 41-50.

CARSTAIRS, G. M., EARLY, D. F., ROLLIN, H. R., et al (1985) Informing relatives about schizophrenia. Bulletin of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, 9, 59-60.

CLAFFERTY, R. A., McCABE, E. & BROWN, K. W. (2000) Telling patients with schizophrenia their diagnosis — patients should be informed about their illness. BMJ, 321, 384-385.[Free Full Text]

CRAG-SCOTMEG WORKING GROUP ON MENTAL ILLNESS (1995) Services for People Affected by Schizophrenia. A Good Practice Statement. Edinburgh: The Scottish Office.

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL SECURITY (1988) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Care and Aftercare of Miss Sharon Campbell. London: HMSO.

DRIVER AND VEHICLE LICENSING AGENCY (1995) Medical Aspects of Fitness to Drive. A Guide for Medical Practitioners (Fifth edn). London: HMSO.

FISHER, M. (2000) Patients expect a diagnosis. BMJ, 321, 385.[Free Full Text]

FOULKS, E. F., PERSONS, J. B. & MERKEL, R. L. (1986) The effect of patients' belief about their illness on compliance in psychotherapy. American Journal of Psychiatry, 143, 340-344.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

GENERAL MEDICAL COUNCIL (1998) Good Medical Practice. London: GMC.

GOLDMAN, C. R. & QUINN, F. L. (1988) Effects of a patient education programme in the treatment of schizophrenia. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 39, 282-286.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

KING, E. (1994) Suicide in the mentally ill. An epidemiological sample and implications for clinicians. British Journal of Psychiatry, 165, 658-663.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

KING, J. (2000) What in fact is schizophrenia? BMJ, 320, 800.[Free Full Text]

LALLY, S. J. (1989) "Does being in here mean there's something wrong with me?" Schizophrenia Bulletin, 15, 253-265.

LEAVEY, G., KING, M., COLE, E., et al (1997) First-onset psychotic illness: patients' and relatives' satisfaction with services. British Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 53-57.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

LUDERER, H. J. & BOCKER, F. M. (1993) Clinicians' information habits, patients' knowledge of diagnoses and etiological concepts in four different clinical samples. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 88, 266-272.[Medline]

McDONALD-SCOTT, P., MACHIZAWA, S. & SATOH, H. (1992) Diagnostic disclosure: a tale in two cultures. Psychological Medicine, 22, 147-157.[Medline]

MAIN, M. C., GERACE, L. M. & CAMILLERI, D. (1993) Information sharing concerning schizophrenia in a family member: adult siblings perspectives. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 7, 147-153.[CrossRef][Medline]

PENDLETON, D. & HASLER, J. (eds) (1983) Doctor Patient Communication. England: Academic Press.

PENN, D. L., GUYNAN, K., DAILY, T., et al (1994) Dispelling the stigma of schizophrenia: what sort of information is best? Schizophrenia Bulletin, 20, 567-578.

RITCHIE, J. (1994) Report of the Inquiry into the Care and Treatment of Christopher Clunis. London: HMSO.

SARTORIUS, N. (1997) Fighting schizophrenia and its stigma. A new World Psychiatric Association educational programme. British Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 297.[Free Full Text]

SAUGSTAD, L. F. & ODEGARD, A. (1983) Persistent discrepancy in international diagnostic practice since 1970. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 68, 501-510.[Medline]

SCOTTISH INTERCOLLEGIATE GUIDELINES NETWORK (1998) Psychosocial Interventions in the Management of Schizophrenia. Edinburgh: Royal College of Physicians.

SMITH, J., BIRCHWOOD, M., HADDRELL, A. (1992) Informing people with schizophrenia about their illness: The effect of residual symptoms. Journal of Mental Health, 1, 61-70.

SVENSSON, B. & HANSSON, L. (1994) Patient satisfaction with inpatient psychiatric care. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 90, 379-384.[Medline]

WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (1992) The ICD—10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders. Geneva: WHO.

This article has been cited by other articles:

				K. F. Chung and M. C. Wong Experience of stigma among Chinese mental health patients in Hong Kong Psychiatr. Bull., December 1, 2004; 28(12): 451 - 454. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				B. Schneider, H. Scissons, L. Arney, G. Benson, J. Derry, K. Lucas, M. Misurelli, D. Nickerson, and M. Sunderland Communication Between People With Schizophrenia and Their Medical Professionals: A Participatory Research Project Qual Health Res, April 1, 2004; 14(4): 562 - 577. [Abstract] [PDF]

				B. Wright, G. Casswell, D. White, and I. Partridge Family Work in Adolescent Psychosis: The Need for More Research Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, January 1, 2004; 9(1): 61 - 74. [Abstract] [PDF]

				C. Lauber and W. Rossler Relatives and their attitude to early detection of schizophrenic psychosis Psychiatr. Bull., April 1, 2003; 27(4): 134 - 136. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

This Article Abstract Full Text (PDF) Submit an eLetter Alert me when this article is cited Alert me when eLetters are posted Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via CrossRef Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Clafferty, R. A. Articles by Brown, K. W. Search for Related Content PubMed Articles by Clafferty, R. A. Articles by Brown, K. W.