| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| British Journal of Psychiatry | Advances in Psychiatric Treatment | All RCPsych Journals |
|
|
|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist, South London and Maudsley NHS Trust, Denis Hill Unit, Bethlem Royal Hospital, Monks Orchard Road, Beckenham, Kent BR3 3BX
Specialist Registrar in Forensic Psychiatry, Broadmoor Hospital, Crowthorne, Berkshire
Airport Medical Services, Horley, Surrey
Air travel is a rapid and efficient mode of travel nationally and internationally. People with a psychiatric disorder can usually travel safely, but may at times require an escort. People whose mental state or behaviour are disturbed are not fit to travel until stability has been achieved. Suicidal or homicidal behaviour by those so disposed are fortunately rare, but can be catastrophic in outcome. Careful assessment is necessary, and psychiatrists are advised to be more aware of the possibility of liaison with airport medical services when appropriate.
Despite a recent reduction in the number of passengers on commercial aircraft following acts of terrorism, war in Iraq, communicable diseases such as severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) and a down-turn in the global economy, air transportation continues to convey millions of people each year across the world. Among this multitude of air passengers are an unknown number of people with mental disorder. Aspects of air travel relevant to psychiatric evaluation are reviewed here.
Prior to departure
Fitness to travel
Most people with pre-existing medical or psychiatric conditions are able to
fly on a commercial aircraft without difficulty. ‘Fear of flying’
courses run by the major airlines may be helpful for some. All travellers
should preferably be fully vaccinated, covered by insurance, and prepared for
the demands of the journey and of their destination. Assessment of fitness to
travel is advisable following recent illness, hospitalisation, injury, surgery
or instability of an acute or chronic condition, or where special services are
required such as oxygen, use of a stretcher, or authority to carry or use
accompanying medical equipment. Passengers with mental illness are required to
be in a stable condition to travel alone. In other cases an appropriately
trained health professional - usually a nurse, but sometimes a doctor - should
be provided as an escort, with access to medication to calm the patient if
necessary. Liaison with the airport medical services may be under-utilised and
should be encouraged where appropriate.
Reasons for travel by air
People who are mentally disordered may, like any citizen, want to travel
for reasons of vacation, recreation, business or visiting friends or
relatives, or at times for pilgrimage to places of religious or spiritual
focus. Additionally, people may occasionally travel for reasons activated by
an abnormal mental state (Miller &
Zarcone, 1968). Psychiatric patients may be transferred from the
unit to which they were admitted back to their catchment area unit
(Favazza & Schaefer, 1970); sometimes the air carrier that brought the patient may be obliged to take them
back. The trip might be made for rehabilitation or compassionate reasons
during the person’s in-patient stay, with potential adverse media
publicity in forensic cases (Gekosi &
Sayed, 2003). Repatriation of patients to their country of origin
may occur under section 86 of the Mental Health Act 1983, for people
categorised as mentally ill, detained on a treatment order and with the
approval of a mental health review tribunal, although voluntary arrangements
are more common (Green & Nayani,
2000). Deportation under immigration legislation is also
undertaken when ordered by a court or the Home Office, and psychiatrists may
be requested to advise on the mental health aspects of such proposed
decisions.
Airport syndrome
Miller & Zarcone (1968)
described a small number of cases of people who were found in a
psychiatrically disturbed state at San Francisco airport, some of whom
required admission to the local psychiatric hospital. In some of these cases
the person had gone to the airport without attempting to travel; in other
cases the person was removed from an aircraft just before departure, or had
just landed at the airport, sometimes as a stopover between connecting
flights. The majority of these people were found to suffer from a psychotic
illness and travel to the airport was in some way a product of this illness,
with a tendency in some cases for repeated visits. Subsequent studies have
indicated similar findings (see, for example,
Wieshmann et al,
2001). ‘Airport wandering’ is rare, but should be
recognised as a possible manifestation of severe mental illness.
In flight
In-flight medical or psychiatric emergencies
In a study by Matsumoto & Goebert
(2001), only 3.5% of all
medical in-flight emergencies in the USA were categorised as due to
psychiatric illness. In 90% of the latter, the diagnosis was that of an
anxiety state, and in only 4% was it a psychotic disorder. For anxiety states,
the onset is usually prior to boarding and continues throughout the flight,
with more reports of anxiety on longer flights. One unusual case has been
described of a man complaining of physical ill-health, which resulted in
diversion of the plane for his hospitalisation, the subsequent diagnosis being
‘jet-set Munchausen syndrome’
(Addison & Talan, 1974). None the less, patients with psychiatric disorders whose behaviour is regarded
as unpredictable, aggressive, disorganised, disruptive or unsafe are felt
unsuitable for travel by air (Aerospace
Medical Association, 1996). Patients with alcohol or drug
dependency problems should have completed detoxification before travelling to
avoid in-flight withdrawal reactions
(Goodwin, 2000). Statistics
pertaining to problems associated with illegal drug use on aircraft are not
available, but such substances may at times contribute to in-flight
emergencies (Lyman & Mohler,
1985).
Although the frequency of psychiatric emergencies is much lower than that of other medical emergencies in-flight, the public is likely to be less tolerant of such incidents, and indeed the control of disturbed behaviour in an aircraft poses much greater potential hazards than on the ground. Seriously dangerous incidents in the air are fortunately statistically rare, but have a high public impact.
In cases in which comorbid physical illness is also present, psychiatric patients will need to heed advice on its management. Patients and their escorts should have their medication readily accessible in their hand luggage, rather than packed in a suitcase.
Suicide and homicide
Suicidal ideation may occur during flight in people who are mentally unwell
(Miller & Zarcone, 1968;
Wieshmann et al,
2001). On rare occasions, the aircraft itself is used as the means
of suicide. Lester (2002)
described two instances of commercial aircraft crashing as a result of a
suicidal passenger killing the pilot and co-pilot, with the subsequent death
of all the passengers. In each case the perpetrator had purchased life
insurance, presumably to benefit his family. The use of private aeroplanes for
suicide by the pilot has also been noted
(Jones, 1977). Maulen &
Faust (1990) estimated that
2-3% of all aviation accidents may be due to suicide. Maulen
(1993) felt that suicide in
aviation was determined by factors similar to other suicides, but that
grandiose and narcissistic elements were also prominent. The crash of flight
EgyptAir 990 in October 1999, about half an hour after take-off from New York
to Cairo, was felt on inquiry to have possibly been caused by a suicidal pilot
(Langewiesche, 2001). In
December 2000, British Airways flight 2069 from London to Nairobi was caused
to dive thousands of feet by a man thought to be suffering from schizophrenia
who entered the cockpit and tried to seize the controls; he was subdued after
a violent struggle (Harris,
2001). Within such cases of psychosis, any grandiose or histrionic
elements might be related to the publicity consequent to precipitating the
crash.
According to Merari (1999), 13% of all hijackings of aircraft between 1947 and 1996 were caused by people who were mentally disturbed; however, no definition of ‘mental disturbance’ was given. Most hijackings were the result of terrorism, which accounted for most of the fatalities. Hoffman (1999) noted that the placing of bombs on aircraft did not originate with terrorism, but continued a series of incidents beginning in 1933 that were motivated by the criminal motive of collecting insurance on family members. Suicide bombing of aircraft came to prominence following the events of 11 September 2001 in the USA (Gordon, 2002). Suicide is a core aspect of psychiatric practice, yet it is probable that the episodes of suicide-homicide carried out by terrorists have no psychopathological basis. Excessive anger and the support of the community to which the person is affiliated may, however, be relevant psychological and social factors (Silke, 2003).
The rarity of suicide or homicide-suicide by aircraft renders such incidents virtually impossible to predict. However, psychiatric evaluation should take into account the presence of either suicidal or homicidal ideation when assessing patients undertaking journeys by air.
Air rage
Passenger misconduct of an aggressive nature during air travel has become a
matter of considerable public concern, and has been increasing in frequency
(Fine, 2002). Such behaviour
may occur either in the airport or in flight; with estimates of some 12 000
episodes of disruptive passenger behaviour in 2000
(Anonymous & Thomas, 2001).
Alcohol consumption is associated with air rage in about a third of cases,
with smoking-related issues in about another third
(Moffatt, 2002). Although
occasional instances may be ascribed to mental illness, the main factors
associated with air rage are alcohol misuse, ‘no smoking’ rules,
arguments with flight attendants, drug abuse
(Fine, 2002), environmental
crowding on the aircraft, delays and lack of information.
At the destination
Jet lag
Jet lag is caused by the desynchronisation between various body and
environmental rhythms (Herxheimer &
Waterhouse, 2003). Jet lag needs to be distinguished from the
effects of travel fatigue, which is common on long-haul flights. Katz et
al (2002) found that jet
lag can induce relapse in an existing psychiatric illness. Whether this is due
to the change in time zones or to the effects of sleep disruption is not
entirely clear (Arehart-Treichel,
2002).
Nature of the destination
Some Israeli psychiatric authors have described the ‘Jerusalem
syndrome’ (Bar-El et al,
2000). Other Israeli colleagues dispute that this is a specific
syndrome; instead, they consider it to be a variant of a schizophrenic illness
(Kalian & Witztum, 2000), and point to examples of pilgrimage to Jerusalem over many centuries made by
people for whom the journey was not the trigger for this psychosis
(Kalian & Witztum, 2002).
Nonetheless, some people with pre-existing psychosis might become overwhelmed
psychologically by places with strong emotional association. A similar
phenomenon may be that of ‘Stendhal syndrome’, in which an acute
psychotic reaction occurs in art-loving tourists visiting Florence
(Magherini, 1992).
Psychiatrists therefore need to take account of the nature of the
patient’s destination and factors there that might contribute to any
relapse. Sufficient supplies of medication should also be carried, in case of
unexpected delay in the return flight. Account should also be taken of any
interpersonal emotional factors that the patient might experience during the
visit.
Conclusions
Most people with mental disorders travel uneventfully, but in some cases psychiatric evaluation is necessary. Airport medical services may be able to provide valuable assistance.
References
ADDISON, T. E. & TALAN, K. H. (1974) Jet-set Munchausen syndrome. New England Journal of Medicine, 291, 1195.
AEROSPACE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION (1996) Medical guidelines for air travel. Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 74, A13 -A14.
ANONYMOUS & THOMAS, A. R. (2001) Air Rage: Crisis in the Skies. New York: Prometheus Books.
AREHART-TREICHEL, J. (2002) Jet lag may trigger mental
illness relapse. Psychiatric News,
37, 29-30.
BAR-EL, Y., DURST, R., KATZ, G., et al (2000)
Jerusalem syndrome. British Journal of Psychiatry,
176, 86-90.
FAVAZZA, A. R. & SCHAEFER, D. L. (1970) Arranging for air transportation of the mentally ill. American Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 133 -136.
FINE, E.W. (2002) Air rage: implications for forensic psychiatry. American Journal of Forensic Psychiatry, 23, 29-44.
GEKOSI, A. & SAYED, V. (2003) Plane crazy. News of the World, 25 May, 23 .
GOODWIN, T. (2000) In-flight medical emergencies: an
overview. BMJ, 321, 1338
-1341.
GORDON, H. (2002) The ‘suicide’ bomber: is
it a psychiatric phenomenon? Psychiatric Bulletin,
26, 285
-287.
GREEN, L. & NAYANI, T. (2000) Repatriating
psychiatric patients. Psychiatric Bulletin,
24, 405
-408.
HARRIS, P. (2001) Passengers in Kenya terror flight to sue BA. The Observer, 11 March.
HERXHEIMER, A. & WATERHOUSE, J. (2003) The
prevention and treatment of jet lag. BMJ,
326, 296
-297.
HOFFMAN, B. (1999) Aviation security and terrorism: an analysis of the potential threat to air cargo integrators. In Aviation, Terrorism and Security (eds P. Wilkinson & B. M. Jenkins), pp. 54-69. London: Frank Cass.
JONES, D. R. (1977) Suicide by aircraft: a case report. Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 48, 455 -459.
KALIAN, M. & WITZTUM, E. (2000) Comments on
Jerusalem syndrome. British Journal of Psychiatry,
176, 492.
KALIAN M. & WITZTUM, E. (2002) Jerusalem syndrome as reflected in the pilgrimage and biographies of four extraordinary women from the 14th century to the end of the second millennium. Mental Health, Religion and Culture, 5, 1 -16.
KATZ, G., KNOBLER, H. Y., LAIBEL, Z., et al (2002) Time zone change and major psychiatric morbidity: the results of a 6-year study in Jerusalem. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 43, 37 -40.[CrossRef][Medline]
LANGEWIESCHE, W. (2001) The Crash of EgyptAir 990. Atlantic Monthly, 288, 41 -52.
LESTER, D. (2002) Suicide and aircraft. Crisis, 23, 2 .[Medline]
LYMAN, J. L. & MOHLER, S. R. (1985) The air line passenger undergoing withdrawal or overdose from narcotics or other drugs. Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 56, 451 -456.[Medline]
MAGHERINI, G. (1992) Syndrome di Stendhal. Milan: Fettrinelli.
MATSUMOTO, K. & GOEBERT, D. (2001) In-flight psychiatric emergencies. Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 72, 919 -923.[Medline]
MAULEN, B. (1993) An aeronautic suicide attempt. Suicide and self-destructive behaviour in aviation. Crisis, 14, 68 -70, 82.[Medline]
MAULEN, B. & FAUST, V. (1990) Suizid mit dem Flugzeug. Münchener Medizinische Wochenschrift, 132, 778 -780.
MERARI, A. (1999) Attacks on civil aviation: trends and lessons. In Aviation, Terrorism and Security (eds P. Wilkinson & B. M. Jenkins), pp. 9-26. London: Frank Cass.
MILLER, W. B. & ZARCONE, V. (1968) Psychiatric behaviour disorders at an international airport. Archives of Environmental Health, 17, 360 -365.[Medline]
MOFFATT, G. K. (2002) A Violent Heart: Understanding Aggressive Individuals. London: Praeger.
SILKE, A. (2003) The psychology of suicide terrorism. In Terrorists, Victims and Society (ed. A. Silke), pp. 93 -108. Chichester: Wiley.
WELLER, M. P. & JAUHAR, P. (1987) Wandering at Heathrow Airport by the mentally unwell. Medicine, Science and the Law, 27, 37 -39.
WIESHMANN, U. C., ANJOYEB, M. & LUCAS, B. B.
(2001) Severe mental illness and airports - the scope of the
problem. Psychiatric Bulletin,
25, 261
-264.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| British Journal of Psychiatry | Advances in Psychiatric Treatment | All RCPsych Journals |
