Psychiatric Bulletin (2007) 31: 192. doi: 10.1192/pb.31.5.192
© 2007 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Work-related stress in psychiatry
Amy M. Macaskill, Specialist Registrar in General Adult Psychiatry
Royal Cornhill Hospital, 26 Cornhill Road, Aberdeen AB25 2ZH, email:
amy.macaskill{at}nhs.net
I read with admiration Dr Harrisons report on work-related stress
(Psychiatric Bulletin, October 2006, 30, 385-387) but I felt a
sense of disappointment that we as psychiatrists and the wider medical
profession continue to deny our health needs and general fallibility, and that
our employers exhibit similar impotence.
Our training focuses our energies on succeeding both academically and later
clinically. We are a competitive breed, entering our working life with high
personal expectations of our performance on a day-to-day basis. The effect of
daily consultation with morbidity and mortality on ourselves has to be
addressed somehow. Denial becomes a handy defence mechanism.
As a profession we are more likely to develop alcohol misuse and dependence
problems, as well as having a higher suicide rate. Yet how often do the
precursors to these go unchecked or unnoticed. Taking time off sick is often
accompanied by guilt and a sense of failure. We seem to believe that it
shouldnt happen to us.
Currently, our junior doctors are in a heightened state of performance
anxiety as Modernising Medical Careers goes live. The usual anxieties related
to finding a job are magnified considerably by the number of jobs being
applied for. How are we and our employers protecting this vital part of the
work force from the inevitable stress-related symptoms that are likely to
ensue? When will we start to be honest with ourselves about our susceptibility
to illness and look to prevent and manage it? When will our employers?